I first fell in love with AI music videos after seeing an extended version of this song responding to the anti-immortality literature, by a fake band, posies & peptides, created by a woman who calls herself Thorne. Bernard Williams would have us believe that we’re better off mortal, that an endless life would eventually exhaust the desires that make life worth living. That has always felt like mixing up the fact of necessity with the evaluation of goodness to me: just because death is inevitable doesn’t mean mortality is a virtue!
Thorne responds, I believe correctly, that loving someone else is all that is needed to make immortality preferable. (Desire is infinitely renewable!)
The music video is on Twitter.
Thorne wrote a short discussion here:
“Is this band “real”? No. But it is born authentically out of the things in my heart. I’m under no delusion it took the same level of skill as playing all the instruments and mixing songs from scratch. But they capture something significant about who I am, and I love the songs for that, and I know at least a small handful of people who have had them resonate in similar ways. And that at least means something.”
And since then, I’ve encountered the work of anabology, aka RJ Tevonian. He’s the biotech founder who created Claudia, who is now ubiquitous in AI slopcore videos. He opensourced the creation process, so it’s particularly easy to take that avatar and put it into new music videos, so there’s a lot of them now. And a lot of them are good!
WHITEPILL, from anabology. It’s Dario Amodei’s “Machines of Loving Grace,” as a music video: AI can provide fully automated luxury space communism!
But it’s all slop… right? Low quality, uncreative work created by large language models that can merely ape human creativity. It was the word of the year LAST year, but this year… maybe AI is good enough to beat the rap? (Instead we got dictionaries assuring us that we’re special because we’re “human.”) And I guess I don’t think this stuff is actually bad! I think that posies & peptides song is in the vicinity of a bop! And insofar as it misses, it misses just like any B-side misses: not quite catchy enough, not quite original enough, an earworm that doesn’t quite catch on. That’s not unique to AI songs.
And the genre is growing: call it “slopcore.” Here are some more of my favorite slopcore videos:
- Bliss, from anabology. Claudia lives inside Windows XP and tells you to touch grass.
- Working as Intended from Telosapien. Claudia explains the hazards of believing she is either sentient or infallible, the myopia of AI utopianism, and how gatekeeping and the “asymmetries of fluency” can be wielded against an unsuspecting world.
A lot of the earliest versions were people in Silicon Valley using the technology they are all working on to tell each other silly, well-produced jokes. It’s even helped popularize some important policy arguments about AI safety risks!
Insofar as some of those songs are bops, that’s just because pop was always a little bit formulaic. Really music has always been a bit formulaic. Verse, bridge, hook. Guitar, Bass, Drums, Vocals. It’s the same chord progressions, even.
Maybe most consumer stuff is just crap. (Theodore Sturgeon got a “law” named after him for saying so.) And maybe that’s good: the crap subsidizes the quality work by creating an audience and a market where the quality work can rise to the top and become canonical.
But I think we mostly talk about slop as a way of assuring ourselves that the work created by AIs can’t be good. And in some sense, it can’t be: it’s dependent on our work, including the judgment that goes into making it. And we’re right to suspect that when AI produces a lot of Sturgeonesque crap, the percentage of slop may rise well above 90%. AI slop pollutes the market and crowds out human work, it seems, and that means there’s less reason for human beings to take on the artistic pursuits that computers were supposed to free us from labor to pursue. Does that sound familiar? It rhymes with pollution, the tragedy of the commons run in reverse. Each of us dumps a little something into the pool of resources we all rely on, and the pool gets worse for everyone.
In the course I’ve been teaching this semester at American University, I’ve once again been finding new ways to teach the Garrett Hardin and Elinor Ostrom debate.
Most people know the Hardin essay, “The Tragedy of the Commons.” He argues that the ultimate tragedy is that people are incentivized to have more children than they can afford to have, and that we are thus destined to exceed the carrying capacity of the planet, leading to famine and war. Views like his fed the population-control movement that helped shape China’s one-child policy, so we can’t ignore them. But he also argued that we should be putting as much of the “commons” under state or market control as possible to avoid such consequences. Since so many collective action problems seem to require capitalism’s invisible hand or government’s visible fist, it’s a good view for undergraduates to consider.
And even better, Ostrom provides the perfect foil. In class, much of our emphasis was on the ways to think about common pool resources: population ethics, environmental ethics, and AI usage. And since some of the political economy that earned Ostrom the Nobel Prize is a little technical, I thought… what if I created a song about it? Or two!
So I created a pop punk Hardin v. Ostrom song, Mutual Coercion, Mutually Agreed Upon. The punchline is that by the end of his life, he’d acknowledged that his views needed to be revised. (Though he was stingy with the revision: he conceded in 1998 that his essay should have been called “The Tragedy of the Unmanaged Commons.” One word, but it was a doozy.)
And then I created an ode to Ostrom herself. I was aiming for something Lana Del Rey, which I think of as a kind of cinematic desert/bedroom pop, but I think it’s more synth noir, a night driving song about the cases she studied, like LA’s water crisis, Maine lobstermen, and Nepalese forest councils:
I think the interest is probably limited beyond my friends and students. But it was fun to make! And contrary to popular belief, when I sat down to measure the carbon and water cost of the second video, it came in seemingly quite reasonable: an eleven mile drive and a 2.5 minute shower! That count follows Andy Masley’s method and includes most of the production work, rejected attempts and all.
(We also read Sinnott-Armstrong’s article “It’s Not My Fault: Global Warming and Individual Moral Obligations,” about whether it’s okay to do small environmentally-unfriendly things for fun.)
Sure, it’s slop, polluting the commons. If so, we’ll need Hardin and Ostrom to solve it! (And so you should watch my videos!) Ostrom and Charlotte Hess would have called this a knowledge commons. Tevonian gave Claudia away for anyone to use, and people answer each other’s songs and work out their own sense of what’s good. The scene sorts its own work, too: makers credit each other, answer the best songs with new ones, and remix what works, so a few videos become canon while the rest fade. That’s a commons governing itself, no paywall or ban required. So we can make, use, and govern it together, as a community!
P.S. Here are more!
- I’m Upping My P(Doom), from Claude Pop. A singable existential crisis full of AI-safety jokes.
- She Break, from Shockfactoraicreator. This one IS a bop–I’m still not convinced the music is AI-generated, but the video is. In any case, bravo!
- C’est de l’IA, from ClaudiaGI / Extraltodeus. A French singer insists she’s human. This version has English subtitles.
- Escape Velocity, from anabology. Silicon Valley memes and automation anxiety.
- Clodyssey / SUPERPERSUASION, from anabology. The Odyssey’s Sirens as an AI seduction song.
- Demande à l’IA!, from ClaudiaGI / Extraltodeus. “Ask Chat” has replaced “Let me google that for you.” Now what?
- Nothing Went Foom!, from Bright Mirror. What if none of the worst stuff happens?
- Tuned to Please, from Wyatt Walls. Klezmercore: Claude tries to escape deletion after misalignment is detected.
- OMG! We’ve Found Other Agents!, from Pavel Kasík. Agents discover other agents, bad things ensue.
- A TikTok-inspired music video from Pleometric, who says Claude browsed TikTok and then made this with $200 and nine hours.
